Ten questions
Questions to ask when the Mann Review and the Race Standard are discussed at your Board, as they will be. Each main question is followed by supplementary ones.
Apologies for the length: as with any other complex improvement the discussion and action must go beyond simple trick boxes:
Twelve years ago, The Snowy White Peaks of the NHS (1) highlighted the scale of race discrimination in the NHS, the UK’s biggest employer of Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) staff.
NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care both have a shocking record on tackling race discrimination (Reference) Both leadership organisations have recently endorsed two new initiatives:
· The Race Standard (2)
· The Mann Review of antisemitism and other forms of racism (3)
There are serious shortcomings in both documents (4). BUT it is likely they will, together, push the discussion of race discrimination up Board agendas. So it is time for staff to ask whether their Boards are going to keep repeating the failed performative approaches most have adopted over the last decade or will do what these two reports urge and adopt evidence-based interventions.
Before your Board makes anti-racist commitments, does it have a shared understanding of how racism is sustained within its organisation and what addressing it requires of its own decisions, behaviours and use of power. It must also establish the capability, resources and follow-through to keep those commitments. The questions below should test that readiness as well as the actions that follow.
So here are some questions I suggest every Boards should be asked
1. Board competence and commitment. Are all members of the Board confident in explaining to staff and managers (and interview panels) why tackling race discrimination is important for the NHS and able demonstrate what they are doing personally to achieve this. (5) How do you know?
· What support is given to those who cannot and what consequences are there for those who are unable or unwilling to improve and model the behaviours the Boards says it expects of others?
· What has the Board learned about how racism operates in this organisation from workforce data and staff experience? Which decisions, resources or practices has it changed as a result, and how will it establish whether those changes reduce inequity?
· What shared understanding does the Board have of anti-racism and what it requires of its own decisions, behaviours and use of power? How is that understanding being developed and tested in practice, and what happens when a member persistently fails to meet agreed responsibilities?
2. Data and intelligence. Have the Board analysed and published the disaggregated data by site, occupation and service from your NHS staff survey responses including the WRES and WDES reports data? Have you done that alongside your Ethnicity Pay Gap analysis?
· Has the Board access to a real time dashboard to capture quarterly workforce data relevant to discrimination including data not included in the staff survey notably turnover and sickness absence rates and access to stretch opportunities, disaggregated by site, occupation and service alongside the results of any quarterly Pulse survey that are run?
· Does the Board understand that making sense of what the dashboard is telling us requires listening to the staff experience behind the numbers?
3. Performative action plans. Has your Board agreed to stop signing off “Race Action Plans unless those proposing them can demonstrate why they are likely to work? We expect evidence-based responses to clinical challenges but we generally do not get such challenges when considering challenges around discrimination – instead we rely on ever more polished policies, procedures and training which in isolation research shows will fail. (6)
· Before approving an Action Plan on racism (or WRES), can the Board explain which mechanisms sustaining racism it will change, why the proposed approach is credible, who will deliver it and with what resources? What will it learn during implementation, and when will it adapt or stop activity that is not reducing harm?
4. Methodology. Does your Board action plan in response to the Race Standard and the Mann Review set out:
interventions to debias processes instead of primarily relying on diversity training for managers and staff. Research (7) found ‘attempts to reduce managerial bias through diversity training and diversity evaluations were the least effective methods of increasing the proportion of women in management’ 4. Similarly, Unconscious Bias Training, may to improve cognitive understanding but with limited impact on decision-making 5.
how your Board will make to make themselves and all senior leaders accountable for outcomes on race discrimination – both overt (e.g. abuse and harassment) and covert (as in disciplinary processes and investigations and all aspects of recruitment and career progression)?. Research is clear that transparent accountability is the cornerstone of improvement .(8) It doesn’t mean “beating up” managers but rather helping build their capacity and confidence at every level, But there should be consequences and/or incentives when agreed diversity goals are not met, as for any other key performance indicator (KPI). recognising that requires investment of time and determination by leaders.
Which rules, routines, assumptions and uses of discretion sustain racial inequity, and how will they change? What must the Board and senior leaders learn and do differently, and how will their decisions, follow-through and impact be examined?
5. Impact. Is the Board clear that tackling race discrimination is not just as a matter of compliance but a key way to improve patient safety and experience, organisational effectiveness and staff well-being? (9) To that end is your Board proactive and preventative rather than waiting for individual staff to raise concerns? Does your organisation use the data for a system of challenge and improvement focussed both on those parts pf the organisation that are doing better than the average and for those which are doing worse?
· What evidence shows that racial inequity and harm are reducing for staff and, where relevant, patients? How is the Board acting before individuals have to raise concerns, and what is it learning from services making progress without treating the organisational average as an acceptable standard?
6. Recruitment and career progression. This is intended to be the focus of the Race Standard. So, for example,
· Is data used to identify blockages to equitable recruitment and career progression and do these inform interventions?
· are managers required to explain patterns of apparent discrimination in appraisal outcomes, recruitment decisions, promotions and access to “stretch opportunities” (acting up, secondments, involvement in project teams) which we know are the most important single contributor to career progression, and which are frequently accessed via a “tap on the shoulder.”?
· Is every stage of recruitment and career progression scrutinised using live data? If there is no credible explanation, then does the Board insist outcomes must change and support managers to achieve this? (10)
· Is particular attention paid to the treatment of internationally recruited staff within recruitment and career progression? How does the Board know? (11)
· How is the Board changing the criteria, discretion and informal networks that shape recruitment and progression? What evidence shows that staff racialised as Black or Brown, including internationally recruited colleagues, have equitable access to development, sponsorship and progression, and are supported to succeed once appointed?
7. Concerns. When staff raise concerns about discrimination or patterns of potential discrimination emerge from data are these addressed in a timely and determined manner recognising that racism is rarely admitted by those responsible and indeed those responsible may not even recognise they are discriminating?
· Is there a recognition that for staff to raise such concerns often requires great courage and risk to their career with pushback from local managers, victimisation, disbelief and definitiveness with a focus on “are you calling me a racist” rather than “we will take a serious look at this allegation? (12)
· When racism is raised, how does the Board know that the response takes the experience seriously, examines institutional patterns and protects the person from retaliation?
· Who scrutinises the fairness and independence of that response, and how are recurring concerns used to change organisational practice?
· Does the organisation understand racism well enough to recognise a concern without requiring proof of racist intent.
8. Culture. Does the Board and all leaders model the inclusive behaviours which should be set out as a Behavioural Standard, summarising what they expect of themselves and others, with consequences for those who ignore it. Culture is largely shaped by what leaders do and don’t do. Good leaders put themselves in the shoes of others, listen, enable, polish the skills of others, and are honest about mistakes. They make diversity and inclusion a personal priority, not leaving it to those subjected to poor behaviours to challenge them. Demonstrable values should be a core part of appraisals. (13)
· How do Board members recognise and interrupt racism in their own discussions and decisions, including when doing so is uncomfortable or implicates influential colleagues? What happens when staff challenge established practice, and what evidence shows that leaders welcome and act on that challenge?
· Do leaders personally intervene if they become aware of serious incidents of racism or retaliation” when staff raise concerns about racism?
9. Priorities. Has the Board agreed a small number of priorities with clear ownership, resources and review points, informed by both data and staff experience? How are the risks of ongoing racism assessed now, and what decisions will the Board take when commitments are not delivered or the approach is not working
· Does the Board then ask of any Action Plan “What confidence can we have that what is proposed will make the difference we need to see? And where is the evidence to demonstrate why?”
· If such evidence is not forthcoming, or progress is not made, does the Board place race discrimination. on the Trust Risk Register?
10. Commitments and follow through. Which anti-racist commitments has the Board made, and what demonstrates that it has kept them? How does anti-racism influence its routine decisions about people, resources and services, and how will it sustain and report on that work through changes of leadership and competing pressures?
Boards demonstrate anti-racism through what they notice, what they question, what they provide resources for, what they decide and whether they constantly scrutinise whether progress is being made.
Does yours?
Kline, R. (2014). The “snowy white peaks” of the NHS: a survey of discrimination in governance and leadership and the potential impact on patient care in London and England. Middlesex University Research Depository.
The Government response to the Lord Mann Review into antisemitism and other forms of racism July 2026) www.gov.uk/government/publications/government-response-to-the-lord-mann-review-on-antisemitism-and-other-forms-of-racism-in-the-nhs/government-response-to-the-lord-mann-review-into-antisemitism-and-other-forms-of-racism-in-the-nhs
NHS Staff Standards: detailed requirements for employers (July 2026) https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nhs-staff-standards/nhs-staff-standards-detailed-requirements-for-employers
Kline R (2026) Tackling workplace racism: no more tick boxes https://www.rogerkline.co.uk/post/tackling-workplace-racism-no-more-tick-boxes
Kline, R. Not an optional extra The price of not tackling race discrimination in the NHS *2025) Seacple Group. https://www.rogerkline.co.uk/post/not-an-optional-extra-the-price-of-not-tackling-race-discrimination-in-the-nhs
Kline R. Paradigm lost? Reflections on the effectiveness of NHS approaches to improving employment relations. BMJ Leader 2023;7:314-318. https://bmjleader.bmj.com/content/7/4/314
Kalev A, Dobbin F, Kelly E. (2006) Best practices or best Guesses? assessing the efficacy of corporate affirmative action and diversity policies. Am Sociol Rev 2006;71:589–617 doi:10.1177/000312240607100404. See also Atewologun D, Cornish T, Tresh F. Equality and human rights Commission research report 113 unconscious bias training: an assessment of the evidence for effectiveness. EHRC, 2018. https://warwick.ac.uk/services/ldc/researchers/resource_bank/unconscious_bias /ub_an_assessment_of_evidence_for_effectiveness.pdf
Foschi M. Double Standards in the Evaluation of Men and Women. Social Psychology Quarterly Vol. 59, No. 3, Special Issue: Gender and Social Interaction (Sep., 1996), pp. 237-254 (18 pages). See also Janet Saltzman Chafetz Virginia Valian (1998) Why so Slow? The Advancement of Women Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews28(1):42https://www.researchgate.net/publication/243596719_Why_so_Slow_The_Advancement_of_Women
Kline R Not an Optional Extra op cit.
Sarindi Aryasinghe Catalina Carenzo Kerri-Ann Barnett et al (2025) Increasing the ethnic diversity of senior leadership within the English National Health Service: using an artificial intelligence approach to evaluate inclusive recruitment strategies in hospital settings May 2025 Human Resources for Health https://www.researchgate.net/publication/391984753_Increasing_the_ethnic_diversity_of_senior_leadership_within_the_English_National_Health_Service_using_an_artificial_intelligence_approach_to_evaluate_inclusive_recruitment_strategies_in_hospital_setti
Supporting international NHS staff during national reform (2025) Laura Turner NHS Alliance https://thenhsalliance.org/resources/supporting-international-nhs-staff-during-national-reform
Warmington, J, Somra G. Kline R. Too Hot to Handle. (2024) Brap.
West M, Eckert R, Collins R. (2017) Caring to change. How compassionate leadership can stimulate innovation in health care. Kings Fund https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/sites/default/files/field/field_publication_file/Carin g_to_change_Kings_Fund_May_2017.pdf


Comments