Russell Brand: Is the BBC “playbook” so different to the NHS response to concerns being raised?
Russell Brand: Is the BBC “playbook” so different to the NHS response to concerns being raised?
Nearly two years ago we were told that “the BBC apologises to staff who ‘felt unable to raise’ Russell Brand concerns” A review was commissioned and it concluded that “a number of people believed the comedian ‘would always get his way and therefore they stayed silent’”.
In response we were told that “The BBC had since “introduced other mechanisms and routes for staff to raise concerns”. (1)
This was the BBC. It could have been the NHS or indeed almost any employer.
When staff raise concerns judged by a manager, or worse a senior leader, to be reputationally threatening in any way then most employers, consciously or otherwise, duck, dive and retaliate following a playbook:
1. Staff member(s) raise a concern
2. If the concern in any way threatens the reputation of a manager or a leader then efforts will be made to persuade the member of staff w=to withdraw any formal concern OR a drawn-out investigation will be launched which draws matters out or has terms of reference making it unlikely the concern will be addressed
3. It quite possible that some staff who previously had similar concerns failed to raise concerns or other staff did raise similar concerns but were not believed or were believed and were warned to keep quiet
4. When it is clear harm will be exposed or legal or regulatory proceedings may be triggered the employer initial tries to stall or suppress and then a “review” is commissioned
5. The review generally takes its time and meanwhile those who raised the concerns experience a degree of isolation, undermining, levels of stress which deep end as the review plods along. Nothing much happens in many cases other than a damage to the careers, reputation or health (or all three) of those who raised concerns. Many investigations are experienced as a form of punishment
6. When the review or investigation is finally concluded there has often been scrutiny of it by senior manager or even by the employer’s lawyers so when published (often as a summary not the full report) it learning is hampered.
7. New policies and procedures follow accompanied by exhortations to staff to be courageous and speak up.
8. Many staff are sceptical because they have seen what has happened to others who did speak up
9. In general, no one is held to account, learning is limited, policies, procedures and training are “improved” Rarely will there be ac countability for those responsible for obstructing the raising of concerns or victimising those who raised them. The worst they can expect is to be be recycled somewhere else.
10.The whistleblower is often damaged by their experience and vows to never raise concerns again, or move job or become very ill.
A few years later the same cycle happens again
The NHS
This may feel familiar to many NHS readers. Not every NHS leader buys into this playbook. But NHS staff have little confidence that raising concerns is safe or effective. is a prime example, . Francis (2015),[2] Kline and Warming (2024)3[] and others all found that many NHS staff are sceptical that raising concerns is effective and believe that by doing so it makes things worse for them personally due to victimisation. The 2023 National NHS Guardian Speaking Up Office report was entitled 'Fear and Futility' and noted a “sharp decline in Freedom to Speak Up Guardians’ perception of the improvements in the Speak Up culture of the healthcare sector…” It noted that: “there is a growing feeling that speaking up in the NHS is futile – that nothing changes as a result.”[4]
NHS staff survey data backs this up. The staff views of 766,000 staff (48% of total staff) responses is that [5]
· 71% would feel secure raising concerns about unsafe clinical practice 2021: 62.08%) Shocking but an improvement since 2021afe to speak up
· 55% are confident that their organisation would address their concern 2021. 59.52%) Shocking and even worse that in 2021
· 60% would feel safe to speak up about anything that concerns them in their 2021: 62.08%)Shocking and even worse than in 2021
· 48% are confident that their organisation would address their concern 2021: 49.77%) Shocking and even worse than in 2021
The responses are despite a shedload of legislation, regulation and exhortation. They are reflected in the never ending cycle of healthcare scandals and inquiries from the Bristol Inquiry (2001), the Mid-Staffordshire Hospital inquiries in 2010 and 2013, and most recently the Ockenden inquiry (2022 and 2026),[5] and the Amos review (2026) all which found staff feared raising concerns or did raise concerns which were ignored
Where allegations of racial discrimination, sexual harassment, management decisions undermining safety are made, or where senior leaders are challenged over their behaviours, it is even worse, This Kline and Warmington report found that of Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) staff who did raise concerns, only 5.4% said they were taken seriously and that their problem was dealt with satisfactorily. The most common outcome is that in 42.7% of cases involving race discrimination was nothing happened.
It is better is some NHS Trusts than others but the current approach is self-evidently not working.
Why?
· Because an approach the relies primarily on policies, procedures and training will not change culture - the methodology adopted is contrary to the best research,
· Because Ministers and too many leaders prefer avoidance and denial until they can no longer engage in that
· Because there are rarely consequences for obstructing staff who raise concerns, let alone victimising them if they do.
Reitz and Higgins (2020) suggest a central reason:
"...power imbalance in organisational roles (as) perhaps the most important factor that makes employee silence such a common experience (and that) “...instigating whistleblowing lines and training employees to be braver or insisting that they speak up out of duty, will achieve little therefore, without leaders owning their status and hierarchy, stepping out of their internal monologue and engaging with the reality of others."[6]
New legislation on being proactive and preventative to identify risks in advance of harassment where protected characteristics are a factor should be a wake-up call to adopt this learning and abandon the playbook summarised above. {7]
Pope and Burnes concluded their research a decade ago thus:
“The NHS exhibits too high a level of collective ego defences and protection of its image and self-esteem, which distorts its ability to address problems and to learn. Organisations and the individuals within them can hide and retreat from reality and exhibit denial; there is a resistance to voice and to “knowing.”[8]
Who can honestly say this is not still true of large parts of the NHS, most notably of national bodies? Is the BBC Russell Brand play book so different to what often happens in the NHS?
The Guardian . June 30th 2025. https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2025/jan/30/bbc-apologises-staff-felt-unable-raise-russell-brand-concerns
Robert Francis. Freedom to Speak Up Review (2015) https://freedomtospeakup.org.uk/
NHS Staff survey 2025 results https://www.nhsstaffsurveys.com/results/
ACAS (2026) Harassment at work. https://www.acas.org.uk/harassment-at-work
Pope R, Burnes B. A model of organisational dysfunction in the NHS. 2013. Journal of Health Organisation and Management, 2013; 27(6): 76-697. https://doi.org/10.1108/JHOM-10-2012-0207.


Comments